Survival Games - Underground Kingdoms

[Jake_MCSG]

sorry just thought I saw yours why not you see mine. (now I realize you already had)

PS: you saw my map? did you like it?

 

[TheOfficialWils]

sorry just thought I saw yours why not you see mine. (now I realize you already had)

No worries

 

[Jake_MCSG]

sorry just thought I saw yours why not you see mine. (now I realize you already had)

PS: you saw my map? did you like it?

??

 

[TheOfficialWils]

??

Honestly I don't know what I think of it I will save my judgement till it is done and I can download it and have a look around.

 

[Fox]

It looks pretty c:

 

[PikachuPals]

This map looks very nice. Hope it gets added.

 

[TheOfficialWils]

It looks pretty c:

This map looks very nice. Hope it gets added.

Thank you both

 

[zorrodc]

Okay I downloaded this and honestly... Meh.
The terraforming was nice in some places, and the theme is good.
But, the builds are awful in most of the map. Awful. Blocky, and mixed wood planks... Ew.
Let's be honest, it really isn't your best work.
I don't want this added, but if they do I just won't vote for it. I guess I'd still play it, though.

 

[TheOfficialWils]

Okay I downloaded this and honestly... Meh.
The terraforming was nice in some places, and the theme is good.
But, the builds are awful in most of the map. Awful. Blocky, and mixed wood planks... Ew.
Let's be honest, it really isn't your best work.
I don't want this added, but if they do I just won't vote for it. I guess I'd still play it, though.

I'm going to disagree with you. The terraforming is acctually really nice to start off with its better than in many of the maps on the servers. I do see where you are coming from with the builds though but I wouldn't describe them as aweful, they may be a bit below par but they are not that bad.

Being a mod I would have thought that you may have understood the concept of constructive critism rather than just flat out insulting me and the map but apparently you don't.

 

[zorrodc]

I'm going to disagree with you. The terraforming is acctually really nice to start off with its better than in many of the maps on the servers. I do see where you are coming from with the builds though but I wouldn't describe them as aweful, they may be a bit below par but they are not that bad.

Being a mod I would have thought that you may have understood the concept of constructive critism rather than just flat out insulting me and the map but apparently you don't.

I have previously replied to this with constructive feedback, I believe I was one of the first. And the terraforming of the underground is good, but the bit across the top is where it gets shaky (I can see the WE.)
I am not insulting you.
I am not bashing your map.
I am not even trying to make people hate it or vote no.
If it gets on, good for you. If not, I'm ambivalent.
This is also my opinion, and I am allowed to state it. It has next to no relevance on if this map gets added- I am not on the map committee. There's no reason to get all huffy

 

[TheOfficialWils]

I have previously replied to this with constructive feedback, I believe I was one of the first. And the terraforming of the underground is good, but the bit across the top is where it gets shaky (I can see the WE.)
I am not insulting you.
I am not bashing your map.
I am not even trying to make people hate it or vote no.
If it gets on, good for you. If not, I'm ambivalent.
This is also my opinion, and I am allowed to state it. It has next to no relevance on if this map gets added- I am not on the map committee. There's no reason to get all huffy

This was your first post about the map you haven't provided any constructive crit. I do understand that the map could be improved but I don't have the time to do it.

 

[zorrodc]

This was your first post about the map you haven't provided any constructive crit. I do understand that the map could be improved but I don't have the time to do it.

I did reply. 5th page. I did not offer any criticism, my apologies. If you want constructive critisism, here:
Spruce up the buildings
Fix terraforming above corn.
However, you said you didn't have the time.
Please stop this mini flame war, this will be my last post on the subject