Maps You'd Like To See Gone

[NovaKaine]

I don't think this thread should have been made. How do you think the people who made those maps would feel. They put so much effort and time into those maps. They were good enough for the MCSG staff to accept them. Then you go along and abuse what they have done. You have no right to do that. Be grateful for the effort those map makers have put in.

I see where you are coming from, and I think most of us understand that the map makers have feelings too. But this is all based on opinion. Some people don't like a map, some people do.

 

[UltimateAFS]

I don't think this thread should have been made. How do you think the people who made those maps would feel. They put so much effort and time into those maps. They were good enough for the MCSG staff to accept them. Then you go along and abuse what they have done. You have no right to do that. Be grateful for the effort those map makers have put in.

For the most part, this thread is about gameplay, not looks. take atlantis for example, the map itsself is beautiful, but the gameplay is awful. This thread doesnt say that they did a crappy job, but it says that despite their good intentions, the map just doesnt play well. And the people who made those maps KNOW there will be people who don't like them. There is always someone who will not like a map. For instance, i hate Holiday Resort with a burning passion of a thousand suns. The majority of the community still loves the map.

I also might add that most people criticize these maps with legitimate reasons (i.e. sloppy terraforming, bad gameplay, lag, absence of detail) to improve the status of MCSG and make it the best it possibly can. We all appreciate the work the makers have put in, but even they know that not every map is liked by the community.

 

[XxM0lTen_LaVAxX]

For the most part, this thread is about gameplay, not looks. take atlantis for example, the map itsself is beautiful, but the gameplay is awful. This thread doesnt say that they did a crappy job, but it says that despite their good intentions, the map just doesnt play well. And the people who made those maps KNOW there will be people who don't like them. There is always someone who will not like a map. For instance, i hate Holiday Resort with a burning passion of a thousand suns. The majority of the community still loves the map.

I also might add that most people criticize these maps with legitimate reasons (i.e. sloppy terraforming, bad gameplay, lag, absence of detail) to improve the status of MCSG and make it the best it possibly can. We all appreciate the work the makers have put in, but even they know that not every map is liked by the community.

Well put! I couldn't of said better myself.

 

[1qw3er5t6y]

Honestly, those maps are some great freaking builds, but they are not good gameplay.

Wastelands is a joke.
Not even a funny joke..

 

[Harris|DareDevilMan1]

These are my opinions
Wasteland: Horrible terraforming, the worst for PvP, almost no buildings. And to top it of, it was stolen by someone that made this map for MC-With-Guns and Nexus.
Memory of Earth: Gives me more fps lag even more than Ancient Japan. Can't even play it in fast graphics and low render distance. Random blocks everywhere that can break your sprint, and some things that are pretty un-needed..
I've played Fortune Island, TSG3, Treacherous Heights and Fallen Empire, but I go 50/50 on them. But I think Hub Games is pretty fun and a really smart idea. I haven't played any other new maps, except Turbulence which I think is pretty good, so I can't really say if they should be gone or not.

 

[darkai202]

But I think Hub Games is pretty fun and a really smart idea.

Hub Games.

fun

really smart idea.

 

[Harris|DareDevilMan1]

It's my opinion, I know. My opinion sucks xD I really think sometimes why I like hub games.

 

[MCGamerzism]

Wow the poll is interesting :3

 

[Zetzus]

Atlantis = Horrible

It is very simple to kill anybody you desire when getting a weapon from spawn, their only escape route is the ladders leading up, and if someone got a bow and arrows from spawn or was sponsored them then they get more easy kills.

Idea = Add at least one staircase of some sort so that they don't have to gamble on their chance of survival.

 

[Bamber]

So many maps I wanna remove, lol.

 

[SuperxAndrew]

I like to maintain the opinion that all maps are good if they are cared for by their creators. If a creator put all they could into a map and thought it was good enough to share with the public, who are we to say if it is good or bad?

Don't get me wrong, there are plenty of maps that are better than others, but no map is truly bad.

Also, I voted for every single map above, not because it is bad, but because of factual reasons.

Fortune Island -- Probably one of my personal favorites. However, seeing as the terrain is clearly world painter and that the best build looks like a blown up village (the one's that you find in default generated terrain) it should not stay on the servers. It isn't a bad map, but what people got to realize is this:

You can like a unpopular map like Fortune Island more than a popular map like Holiday, but if there are obvious building/gameplay errors should Fortune Island really be kept over Holiday just because of your personal opinion. This is what we are seeing a lot of, people getting offended when a map they like comes up in "remove" threads like this one. However, it isn't about what you like. I love Fortune Island, but I still think it should be removed.

We all have our opinions, but what you guys need to try to do is think beyond yourselves and attempt to think about what is best for the community as a whole and not just for you. You could like Fortune Island better than SG4, but does that really mean that it should be kept instead of the most popular map of all time? Think about it, if this rant made any sense at all.

 

[Ceroria]

Fallen Empire is the most nostalgic map of all time for me. I was crushed when v1 was taken down because it was the first map I ever really played on with intent when I was learning how to get better at MCSG after 8ish months of being of the scale bad.

Teweran SG3 is fun to play on, imo. Not worthy of being removed, but it isn't a great map. I'd put it in the middle, without maps like it (middle-ground maps), we wouldn't have many maps!

Fortune Island has been beloved by me since I first played it. I guess I'm a bit biased because my friend, cyorde, built a lot of it, but still.

My Tracherous Heights route is OP, but otherwise the map isn't the greatest.

Idk, some maps could definitely be removed, like... most of the rest of those honestly