Demon's Breeze: 2/10 This map, is an absolute insult to map makers, the only map I would say is worse than this, is moonlight lake. The only effort required to make this map, is knowing your world edit commands, because that's really all this map requires, just a simple biome change, and switching water to lava. It really pains a map maker to know that something like THIS got put in, over your map.
Freeze Island: 3/10 I give this map a higher rating than demon's breeze, because they did a little more than simply changing the biome. Although, it's not a map where you can say, HEY! This is a cool map! If anything, they should have tried to make it like SG 5 in the sense that a tropical island, had been frozen in, by a freak snowstorm.
Holiday Resort: 7/10 I like this map, I think it's a good map, I have only played one game on it, so that's all I can say.
Valleyside University: 6/10 This map could be a GREAT map, but it's not, it's just good. The terraforming is sub-par, and does not match the theme of the map at all. It feels like you were just plopped down into a man-made arena, instead of somewhere in the real world, with an invisible force field around it, like the real hunger games. Some of the buildings could use a little bit more detail, such as the building "under construction". I personally think it is a good map, but there needs to be some changes, before it's a great map.
Wyvern's Wake: 1/10 Okay this map is absolutely terrible. The structures are horrible, the map is extremely random, and it seems to much like asia games. This map, looks like any other map, on some kid's private server. IMO, the only reason this got accepted, is because most of the map makers where staff members, or ex-staff members.