• Our Minecraft servers are offline but we will keep this forum online for any community communication. Site permissions for posting could change at a later date but will remain online.

Rate the New MCSG Maps, thinking thread

darkai202

Mockingjay
Joined
Aug 24, 2012
Messages
7,802
Reaction score
13,558
Demon's Breeze - 4/10, Honestly ugly, lava kills computers.
Freeze Island - 4/10, I don't like a few of the builds, okay gameplay.
Holiday Resort - 8/10, I actually really like the map and the theme.
Valleyside University - 7/10, Pretty solid map. Good gameplay.
Wyvern's Wake - 2/10, Why... Did they add this. Asiagamesv2
 

Elisha

Peacekeeper
Joined
May 28, 2012
Messages
1,062
Reaction score
1,052
That's YOUR opinion....
People don't really understand these kind of threads. I'm not saying all but yeah, threads about "Your Top 5 MCSG Players" and all those stuffs are basically about our own opinion, some people just had to get in the way of that.
 

ManOfTheBread

Peacekeeper
Joined
May 27, 2012
Messages
1,531
Reaction score
1,328
Demon's Breeze: 2/10 This map, is an absolute insult to map makers, the only map I would say is worse than this, is moonlight lake. The only effort required to make this map, is knowing your world edit commands, because that's really all this map requires, just a simple biome change, and switching water to lava. It really pains a map maker to know that something like THIS got put in, over your map.
Freeze Island: 3/10 I give this map a higher rating than demon's breeze, because they did a little more than simply changing the biome. Although, it's not a map where you can say, HEY! This is a cool map! If anything, they should have tried to make it like SG 5 in the sense that a tropical island, had been frozen in, by a freak snowstorm.
Holiday Resort: 7/10 I like this map, I think it's a good map, I have only played one game on it, so that's all I can say.
Valleyside University: 6/10 This map could be a GREAT map, but it's not, it's just good. The terraforming is sub-par, and does not match the theme of the map at all. It feels like you were just plopped down into a man-made arena, instead of somewhere in the real world, with an invisible force field around it, like the real hunger games. Some of the buildings could use a little bit more detail, such as the building "under construction". I personally think it is a good map, but there needs to be some changes, before it's a great map.
Wyvern's Wake: 1/10 Okay this map is absolutely terrible. The structures are horrible, the map is extremely random, and it seems to much like asia games. This map, looks like any other map, on some kid's private server. IMO, the only reason this got accepted, is because most of the map makers where staff members, or ex-staff members.
 

mgf4

Experienced
Joined
Mar 10, 2013
Messages
353
Reaction score
149
I think that they are all trash except Valley Side University
 

mgf4

Experienced
Joined
Mar 10, 2013
Messages
353
Reaction score
149
You realise that the others are made by staff members? and you just called their maps trash....
I ik I really dislike brezze and the copys of breeze are really annoying I wish we played more of the original maps like Kummarah or Forrest pyke
 

Oblath

Spectator
Joined
Apr 5, 2013
Messages
9
Reaction score
21
Demon's Breeze - 9/10 Personally i really enjoy this map, it's a good map for PvP and to increase your movement. You can use a lot of new strategies, like kicking people into lava, or my own "secret" going into the creeperface and kicking people out of it, when they are trying to get in. -1 Points because i have to turn my sound off :/
Freeze Island - 5/10 This map is very well built, the ice dragon looks so awsome! But it's not a good map to PvP on... Not because of the ice, because everything is flat.
Holiday Resort - 6/10 Blablabla the map is very well built, the structurs are really cool and you can explore alot. But i prefer maps where you can use alot of different tactics to PvP. Anyway in my opinion it's to big and there's way to much water.
Valleyside University - 9/10 I love this map <3. There are a lot of chests, a lot of hidden secrets, the lava jumpn run is simply awsome and it's a good map to PvP on :p . Personally i enjoy that it's not a typical HG map. And -1 Point because (and i know it's not the builders fault) people are not droping any items.
Wyvern's Wake - 8/10 I don't really know why everybody is hating so much on it, but i really enjoy playing on it. The buildings, dragons and all the other creatures are beautiful. There are a lot of chests and if you are doing good you can just hang around and explore the map. Minus 2 points because of the lack of Tier2s and because you can't get to the crafting table at spawn fast enough.
 

wronsiski

Career
Joined
Jul 1, 2012
Messages
630
Reaction score
620
Wyvern's Wake: 1/10 Okay this map is absolutely terrible. The structures are horrible, the map is extremely random, and it seems to much like asia games. This map, looks like any other map, on some kid's private server. IMO, the only reason this got accepted, is because most of the map makers where staff members, or ex-staff members.
So I'd like to clarify something. This map was not added because I'm a staff member, it was added due to the fact that the senior staff like it... a lot. I'm am somewhat disgusted that you are comparing this to asia games, no offense to the guy who made that map. Each biome on Wyvern's wake is unique, hand crafted. Asia games was made on a randomly generated Minecraft world. Whilst Wyvern's wake does diversify in the structure and layout of it's biomes, you will notice that there is only one version of each biome, I am totally fine with the point people are saying about it having too many different biomes, and fair enough it is crammed into a small space. Any other map on some kids server? This map is unique in what it displays and is completely different from any world I have seen. Although I am the creator of this map I am willing to accept feedback about it, so by all means Pm me with your issues.
 

BritishShoop

Peacekeeper
Joined
May 27, 2012
Messages
1,993
Reaction score
1,264
So I'd like to clarify something. This map was not added because I'm a staff member, it was added due to the fact that the senior staff like it... a lot. I'm am somewhat disgusted that you are comparing this to asia games, no offense to the guy who made that map. Each biome on Wyvern's wake is unique, hand crafted. Asia games was made on a randomly generated Minecraft world. Whilst Wyvern's wake does diversify in the structure and layout of it's biomes, you will notice that there is only one version of each biome, I am totally fine with the point people are saying about it having too many different biomes, and fair enough it is crammed into a small space. Any other map on some kids server? This map is unique in what it displays and is completely different from any world I have seen. Although I am the creator of this map I am willing to accept feedback about it, so by all means Pm me with your issues.
I don't see the problem with it. I haven't played it before but the video and screenshots look good!
 

VeteranHeroes

Tribute
Joined
Jun 2, 2012
Messages
32
Reaction score
0
Demon's Breeze: .5/10 Constant lag spikes when getting near lava (can be fixed by turning off sound.) Map seems like it was just //replace 8 10. Chests are in the exact same places as Breeze Island. /overplayed
Freeze Island: 1/10 Seems like this map has a few different chest locations than Demon's Breeze. Although, its pretty much a replica of Demon's Breeze (//replace 8 79). /overplayed
Holiday Resort: 8.5/10 Absolutely an amazing job by the creator of this map! Lots of attractions to visit, much
creativity, and a very nice environment! Although, it might seem as if the chests were just laid down too often.
Valleyside University: 9/10 A lot of hidden secrets and "Easter eggs?" in the map! Very well built and it seems as if the creator did put a lot of time and effort into this map.
Wyvern's Wake: 10/10 Ah, I love the good ol' feel of imagination and majestical feelings! This map brings back some memories from World of Warcraft (don't know why?) and Skyrim. Although, and I don't know if this is mean to be, one of the "Wyverns" at the spawn is actually a dragon. Wyverns don't have arms - only feet and wings, while dragons have both feet and arms.
 

Members online

No members online now.

Forum statistics

Threads
242,192
Messages
2,449,550
Members
523,972
Latest member
Atasci