Survival Games: Catan

[Sean]

It looks good and I like the fact you are trying to bring the nostalgic feeling back. Ill list out the good points and bad points in my opinion.

Good

• Builds look nice.
• Nice idea
• Corn looks nice and simple and should have a good deathmatch.

Bad

• The teraforming is decent but there is nothing that stands out, maybe add a custom tree a arch, something along those lines.
• If you are going for the nostalgic feel I would make the map a bit bigger and remove a few chests and try add in a few secrets that will reward.
• You need a bit more block variation or else it will look very boring.

I hoped this helped but overall you have done a decent job so far, I might download the map later and have a better look and come back with more help but for now I am only judging off the screen shots and info you gave.

 

[Shaunypie87]

It is a good map, but for me there is something missing. It doesn't have much to it, and I think you need to add more detail, because it just looks a little empty to me. It's still a really good map, and I'd like to see it implemented

 

[InsanePickaxe]

It is a good map, but for me there is something missing. It doesn't have much to it, and I think you need to add more detail, because it just looks a little empty to me. It's still a really good map, and I'd like to see it implemented

Thank you, we are working on improvements right now!

 

[Mamiamato24]

As others said above, the map is generally a bit generic. I looked around it a while ago and it was nothing really special :/

 

[InsanePickaxe]

As others said above, the map is generally a bit generic. I looked around it a while ago and it was nothing really special :/

It is meant to be generic, there is nothing wrong with that, a lot of good maps are generic.

 

[Mamiamato24]

It is meant to be generic, there is nothing wrong with that, a lot of good maps are generic.

Well they all usually have something that differentiates them from the rest...I just don't see it in this map.

 

[InsanePickaxe]

It looks good and I like the fact you are trying to bring the nostalgic feeling back. Ill list out the good points and bad points in my opinion.

Good

• Builds look nice.
• Nice idea
• Corn looks nice and simple and should have a good deathmatch.

Bad

• The teraforming is decent but there is nothing that stands out, maybe add a custom tree a arch, something along those lines.
• If you are going for the nostalgic feel I would make the map a bit bigger and remove a few chests and try add in a few secrets that will reward.
• You need a bit more block variation or else it will look very boring.

I hoped this helped but overall you have done a decent job so far, I might download the map later and have a better look and come back with more help but for now I am only judging off the screen shots and info you gave.

Thanks, this has helped, but I don't see how you can comment on the terraforming because you have not seen the map, also where abouts are you talking about adding more block variation?

 

[InsanePickaxe]

Well they all usually have something that differentiates them from the rest...I just don't see it in this map.

Anything you could suggest maybe? Others are saying the map is nice, so if you could maybe suggest something? :c

 

[Mamiamato24]

Anything you could suggest maybe? Others are saying the map is nice, so if you could maybe suggest something? :c

Maybe a big mansion or something?

 

[RC_4777]

Maybe a big mansion or something?

Shhhh

Pics don't seem to work for me...

 

[InsanePickaxe]

Maybe a big mansion or something?

Okay, and then maybe you would like it? lol

 

[InsanePickaxe]

Shhhh

Pics don't seem to work for me...

Really? Icryerytim :'(

Edit: Sh** I fu***** deleted them!

Edit: Sorry for language :'(