You got my vote as well! I want to see this back so badly. The current system:
Pros:
-plays popular maps
Cons:
-doesn't give more survival-themed maps a chance
-destroys... just about every map except for Valleyside, Alaskan Village, Holiday Resort, and SG4
-causes the map with the most OP route to win basically every time (ever wondered why people like Lobby Games?)
-favors donors and makes Member voting almost useless
-causes people to start getting sick of maps they once enjoyed
Please bring this system back. I haven't even played:
Remnant
TSG3
TSG1
SG1
SG2
SG3
SG5
The Lost Zoo
Fallen Empire
Mortal Skies
Fortress Pyke
Those are just the maps that I have never played. There are at least 5 more I can say I've only played once or twice.