• Our Minecraft servers are offline but we will keep this forum online for any community communication. Site permissions for posting could change at a later date but will remain online.

Petition - Change the deleting evidence rule. [200+ Signatures!]

Status
Not open for further replies.

_Rixton

Platinum
Joined
Jul 30, 2014
Messages
13
Reaction score
9
I _Rixton would like to sign the petition. For cscoop!!!!! Let's do this!
 

Nick

Community Engagement & Mapping Team Representative
Joined
May 31, 2013
Messages
3,194
Reaction score
3,414
Fun Fact: If you want someone to respect an idea of yours, a proposal is the way to go. A petition shows that you are going against us currently, whilst a proposal shows that you want to work with us.

[/My 2 cents]
 

Pixelatorx2

Platinum
Joined
Oct 2, 2012
Messages
2,957
Reaction score
2,625
Fun Fact: If you want someone to respect an idea of yours, a proposal is the way to go. A petition shows that you are going against us currently, whilst a proposal shows that you want to work with us.

[/My 2 cents]
A petition doesnt usually come with a solution that works with both sides - in this case, the petition comes with a viable solution & can show you the amount of supporters it has.
 

Nick

Community Engagement & Mapping Team Representative
Joined
May 31, 2013
Messages
3,194
Reaction score
3,414
A petition doesnt usually come with a solution that works with both sides - in this case, the petition comes with a viable solution & can show you the amount of supporters it has.
That's not my point. I'm pointing out that a petition is going against our current system. A written proposal in which you could email us about would be better in my opinion, and I think I agree with the rest of the Sr. Staff when I say this. At the end of the day, you're trying to convince us.

For example when I was suggesting the idea for the community focus group, I didn't start a petition and hey ho, guess what happens every two weeks?

Point being, I wrote a full proposal as shown below:

 
Last edited:

Pixelatorx2

Platinum
Joined
Oct 2, 2012
Messages
2,957
Reaction score
2,625
That's not my point. I'm pointing out that a petition is going against our current system. A written proposal in which you could email us about would be better in my opinion, and I think I agree with the rest of the Sr. Staff when I say this. At the end of the day, you're trying to convince us.

For example when I was suggesting the idea for the community focus group, I didn't start a petition and hey ho, guess what happens every two weeks?

Point being, I wrote a full proposal as shown below:

<iframe src=""></iframe>
(Usually) A petition is to change something, a proposal is to add something.

In your case, you were wanting to add an event - an idea that does no harm. In this case its to change a rule, something that you need support of the community. After getting support (through a petition) you then propose this to the higher-ups.

Which is what I suggest you do, arsenalfcgunners.
 

0nePr0mise

Platinum
Joined
Aug 20, 2014
Messages
2
Reaction score
0
Problem: Deleting evidence even accidentally will result in a permaban (1st offense) for a user who was trying to help the community. For hackers it is a 7 day ban (1st offense) for someone who was doing harm to the community. Recently, some important players including Cscoop and Twee were perma banned for accidentally deleting evidence, and not being aware of the rule.

Solution: A lot of this has controversy has come from people disputing months after there ban was given. I say it is a 7 day 1st offense and permaban 2nd offense for deleting evidence within a month of the report. After a month, they are no longer obligated to keep the video on Youtube. The banned user has had plenty of time to dispute, and they can no longer dispute their ban if the evidence was deleted. If the staff feel that they need the evidence longer, they can screen record the video, so they have it on record. It is unfair to hold someone who was trying to help the community accountable for a video months after. What if they delete their channel and forget about the video?

Petition: To make this change happen, the community needs your support. Reply to this thread with, "I, [insert name here] would like to sign the petition." Then I will add your name to the list. Note: You don't have to agree 100% with the solution to sign, if you are signing you are saying that you want a change to the rules. That change does not necessarily have to be my exact solution.

Players who want change:
arsenalfcgunners
Sean
Harris|DareDevilMan1
Edog and Edog
EricParazak
Cscoop
Jaan
MinedAndCrafted5
Damien // Teepwn
Mamiamato24
Ex0dUs101
beep253
TheMaskedDomo
demonsushi
WertQuadNine
Mint_Sibs
SuperxAndrew
Unknown // Rainbow Derp
AGFire2013

Imanol_Magana
NixGamez
Sidopey
shadowblaze12
Ag | Alex
Aedrift
Joel Maury-Holmes
Twee
I_love_desk
Twistology
AlLuc
mr_pendle
Kerbals
Kauff
niek
Attorah
Jockster2002
Groot
Mooclan
Crackling
ToastySoldier_
Manos
Giolightning
Smizack
xPandq
ChrisComedies
Dantelius
ThisJKid
MeatalclawMC
AuroraV2
xPvPProdigyx
NotCanziano
Timtommytom
Eathuis
Ikanacanyon7
justin69
thedude2012
Qyxr
Frazzel
PuffyCottonCandy
Ranger_zZ
PROxNIGGLES_25
Cat_On_A_Poptart
DoY0uEvenStrafe
frozenpretzel
Raibushi
JCagg
Fusionnuggets
Znike1
Pixelatorx2
547awesomeness
Sim_Man
RyanCx
PaperVinnie53
Shake_Junt00
ItalianJesus
XplodingKiwi
Jam0919
CashFloMoney
Elryst
DaGamerYT
Scrape
ttt6t
CyberPIE
HayHotshot
rawriledino
derrgand
LampsyLegendMC
MCOnThePCAndrew
Metalmate9
Knaala
420oz
yannr00s
ItsCheerry
Yangervis
swiitchbackz
MizadorMC
iBigNub
zCrits_
MineCell
BaconUnicorn
DrRustyPanda611
EricDude01
robbiemcfadden
Bunns
Slagguaron
SertifiedBlocks
ThatFuryFellow
F34RL3555
KrypticMC11
Chris|Bro
Lukeabbott
oshisomethingmeh
FanYG
FS_MonkeyDoesgames
Flixo
darmody101
HomeyGaming
TheFanManiac
IronwoodWB
RobertHDPotatoes
IceWolf608
Xentrik
Lemonz87
The_Man
MiecraftSuperNatural
JokoSwag
WalkerRed
ZachPlayzMC
Lis
Chipyy
10Hearted
HohoPvP
John jennings
GOLD_ninja14
Wyz_Guy
JonJayMan
Total Signatures: 136
Add me to the petition: my name is FrozenDreams
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Members online

No members online now.

Forum statistics

Threads
242,192
Messages
2,449,550
Members
523,970
Latest member
Atasci