• Our Minecraft servers are offline but we will keep this forum online for any community communication. Site permissions for posting could change at a later date but will remain online.

[WEBSITE][SIGN-UP] "Confirmation Question"

GradeZeroGamer

Survivor
Joined
Aug 18, 2013
Messages
145
Reaction score
73
Alright, so I'm sure a majority of you have seen the spambots on this website. I'm not sure whether this suggestion would stop them or not, but here it is anyways:...


A "Confirmation" question! Essentially, when signing up, along with all your other signup questions, theres also a confirmation question, such as...


"What is the default Minecraft characters name" and you would answer Steve.


I think this would essentially stop the spambots. Additionally, the question would change every time.


Thoughts?
 

Fox

Diamond
Joined
May 11, 2013
Messages
3,534
Reaction score
7,220
Yes. I don't like spambots :p , They ugly.
 

OnlyMathias

Peacekeeper
Joined
Jun 22, 2012
Messages
1,678
Reaction score
847
This my work but I'm not sure what we have in place because well I haven't done a confirmation in a while.
 

GradeZeroGamer

Survivor
Joined
Aug 18, 2013
Messages
145
Reaction score
73
I just signed up, and they didn't have one in place, but they should due to spambots.
 

subtato

District 13
Joined
Oct 15, 2012
Messages
1,066
Reaction score
2,191
Alright, so I'm sure a majority of you have seen the spambots on this website. I'm not sure whether this suggestion would stop them or not, but here it is anyways:...


A "Confirmation" question! Essentially, when signing up, along with all your other signup questions, theres also a confirmation question, such as...


"What is the default Minecraft characters name" and you would answer Steve.


I think this would essentially stop the spambots. Additionally, the question would change every time.


Thoughts?
These answers would eventually become part of a large spam database, where spambots would then pull the answers for this eventually. It's inevitable, and the best thing we can continue doing is what I'm doing now.
We're banning / deleting the spambots as we go along, and I'm banning entire datacenters from our website to prevent spambots.
The following is the IP banned list:
142.4.101.64/21 # Manually denied - Thu Aug 1 17:35:18 2013
192.74.224.0/19 # Manually denied - Thu Aug 1 17:36:58 2013
37.187.0.0/16 # Manually denied - Thu Aug 1 17:40:06 2013
142.0.128.0/20 # Manually denied - Thu Aug 1 17:42:27 2013
198.2.192.0/18 # Manually denied - Thu Aug 1 17:44:44 2013
198.200.32.0/19 # Manually denied - Thu Aug 1 23:58:37 2013
137.175.0.0/17 # Manually denied - Thu Aug 1 23:59:24 2013
142.0.32.0/20 # Manually denied - Fri Aug 2 02:00:41 2013
88.160.0.0/11 # Manually denied - Sat Aug 3 19:33:29 2013
142.4.96.0/19 # Manually denied - Tue Aug 6 13:15:40 2013
95.67.80.0/19 # Manually denied - Tue Aug 6 13:17:46 2013
178.73.192.0/18 # Manually denied - Tue Aug 6 17:30:32 2013
199.15.232.0/21 # Manually denied - Wed Aug 7 02:29:26 2013
5.254.144.0/24 # Manually denied - Fri Aug 9 01:33:00 2013
176.31.0.0/16 # Manually denied - Thu Sep 5 19:26:20 2013
199.103.56.0/21 # Manually denied - Thu Sep 5 23:24:35 2013
91.121.0.0/18 # Manually denied - Fri Sep 6 12:02:59 2013
199.195.212.0/22 # Manually denied - Fri Sep 6 14:34:42 2013
66.132.128.0/17 # Manually denied - Fri Sep 6 14:41:12 2013
89.169.128.0/18 # Manually denied - Mon Sep 9 03:55:26 2013
198.100.144.0/20 # Manually denied - Mon Sep 9 03:56:27 2013
58.22.123.147 # Manually denied - Mon Sep 9 03:56:59 2013
209.21.64.0/19 # Manually denied - Mon Sep 9 04:57:21 2013
192.200.96.0/19 # Manually denied - Mon Sep 9 13:07:02 2013
188.165.0.0/16 # Manually denied - Mon Sep 9 13:09:57 2013
125.62.124.53 # Manually denied - Mon Sep 9 13:14:23 2013
124.253.241.26 # Manually denied - Mon Sep 9 13:15:20 2013
202.126.122.147 # Manually denied - Mon Sep 9 13:15:32 2013

The IP ranges (IP addresses with /XX afterwards) are massive amounts of IPs. For example, a /24 is 256 IP addresses. A /21 is 2048 IP addresses.
We ensure that we're only banning proxies and datacenters, thus any home connections will not be blocked.
 
Joined
Aug 14, 2013
Messages
586
Reaction score
590


No, please no captcha.
Well we do have a captcha text translator, but I agree, questions would only lead to complications. What if a non-English speaker wants to play, or what if it's an absolute noob? There are too many "what if's".
 

GradeZeroGamer

Survivor
Joined
Aug 18, 2013
Messages
145
Reaction score
73
These answers would eventually become part of a large spam database, where spambots would then pull the answers for this eventually. It's inevitable, and the best thing we can continue doing is what I'm doing now.
We're banning / deleting the spambots as we go along, and I'm banning entire datacenters from our website to prevent spambots.
The following is the IP banned list:
142.4.101.64/21 # Manually denied - Thu Aug 1 17:35:18 2013
192.74.224.0/19 # Manually denied - Thu Aug 1 17:36:58 2013
37.187.0.0/16 # Manually denied - Thu Aug 1 17:40:06 2013
142.0.128.0/20 # Manually denied - Thu Aug 1 17:42:27 2013
198.2.192.0/18 # Manually denied - Thu Aug 1 17:44:44 2013
198.200.32.0/19 # Manually denied - Thu Aug 1 23:58:37 2013
137.175.0.0/17 # Manually denied - Thu Aug 1 23:59:24 2013
142.0.32.0/20 # Manually denied - Fri Aug 2 02:00:41 2013
88.160.0.0/11 # Manually denied - Sat Aug 3 19:33:29 2013
142.4.96.0/19 # Manually denied - Tue Aug 6 13:15:40 2013
95.67.80.0/19 # Manually denied - Tue Aug 6 13:17:46 2013
178.73.192.0/18 # Manually denied - Tue Aug 6 17:30:32 2013
199.15.232.0/21 # Manually denied - Wed Aug 7 02:29:26 2013
5.254.144.0/24 # Manually denied - Fri Aug 9 01:33:00 2013
176.31.0.0/16 # Manually denied - Thu Sep 5 19:26:20 2013
199.103.56.0/21 # Manually denied - Thu Sep 5 23:24:35 2013
91.121.0.0/18 # Manually denied - Fri Sep 6 12:02:59 2013
199.195.212.0/22 # Manually denied - Fri Sep 6 14:34:42 2013
66.132.128.0/17 # Manually denied - Fri Sep 6 14:41:12 2013
89.169.128.0/18 # Manually denied - Mon Sep 9 03:55:26 2013
198.100.144.0/20 # Manually denied - Mon Sep 9 03:56:27 2013
58.22.123.147 # Manually denied - Mon Sep 9 03:56:59 2013
209.21.64.0/19 # Manually denied - Mon Sep 9 04:57:21 2013
192.200.96.0/19 # Manually denied - Mon Sep 9 13:07:02 2013
188.165.0.0/16 # Manually denied - Mon Sep 9 13:09:57 2013
125.62.124.53 # Manually denied - Mon Sep 9 13:14:23 2013
124.253.241.26 # Manually denied - Mon Sep 9 13:15:20 2013
202.126.122.147 # Manually denied - Mon Sep 9 13:15:32 2013

The IP ranges (IP addresses with /XX afterwards) are massive amounts of IPs. For example, a /24 is 256 IP addresses. A /21 is 2048 IP addresses.
We ensure that we're only banning proxies and datacenters, thus any home connections will not be blocked.

So couldn't you just, say reset the stats from this database every so often or would that not be possible? Again, if we put a few questions in the rotation or change the rotation every month it may make it more difficult for them





No, please no captcha.
It would help if you actually specified why you don't want this, rather than just immediately shooting it down.


Well we do have a captcha text translator, but I agree, questions would only lead to complications. What if a non-English speaker wants to play, or what if it's an absolute noob? There are too many "what if's".
If it's an absolute noob, it shouldn't be too troubling to look it up on the internet. As for your second question, this may be a good time to bring up "setting default language" for the website.
 

Levah

District 13
Joined
Jul 8, 2012
Messages
2,861
Reaction score
2,525
Captcha. It may be bad but it helps us from spam bots.
 

Members online

No members online now.

Forum statistics

Threads
242,192
Messages
2,449,550
Members
523,972
Latest member
Atasci