The one thing I would change about MCSG is...

[Zeno]

Tournaments are a must. And I believe the voting system could be changed to allow more votes in the voting pool, but otherwise everything is pretty good.

Oh, one more thing:

Dem puppies.
Ermhagherd.

 

[Lukas Bisket]

I would change it so that donors kick players with the least played games instead of the last to join.

That's a bad idea. Why kick people who have barely played? So the mcsg community is filled with veterans?

 

[Mitsolides]

I would change it so that donors kick players with the least played games instead of the last to join.

It seems fair the way it is but their should be a VIP thing for donors like only 5 donors in a game and 19 tributes something along those lines

 

[Mitsolides]

Tournaments are a must. And I believe the voting system could be changed to allow more votes in the voting pool, but otherwise everything is pretty good.

Oh, one more thing:

Dem puppies.
Ermhagherd.

Dem puppies indeed

 

[Zeno]

It seems fair the way it is but their should be a VIP thing for donors like only 5 donors in a game and 19 tributes something along those lines

But then donors would have a harder time then regular people

That doesn't make much sense.

 

[Toa-Rex]

Lately the games haven't been as interesting as they used to be. I remember being in a 24 player server and the games would last 60 minutes. Mainly because it would end up being a team of 2 vs. one single player. And it wouldn't go directly to deathmatch because it required 2 tributes remaining for the game to go to deathmatch. Me, being the single player a lot of the time, would have to stalk them a bit more and wait for one to make the foolish move of moving into a cave or wandering away from his partner to go get a chest.

Another thing that made the games interesting was when mobs played a big role in how the game played out. Players who weren't well equipped used to have to hide in trees or buildings at night to wait out for the monsters to go away when the sun rose in the morning. Now a days there are hardly any mobs because their spawn rates have been dramatically decreased. I know that the mobs weren't real popular with the majority but I liked having long games. They weren't fun to watch but they were a blast if you where the player, in game, running around, hoping that a creeper doesn't blow you up, or that a player will jump at you.

To me, a lot of the old adventure feel has gone away because of some of these things. When I was new to this when these servers first came out, it was awesome to be in game and to have your heart racing because you just made it into the top 5! That was quite challenging because you would have to fend off mobs and had to be watching your back at every second.

I miss the old days. It's not that I don't like what we have now, it is completely fine with me, but it just isn't as fun as it used to be.

One thing I would change about mcsg is bringing it back to how it was before sg3 was released.

that was deep man

 

[Mitsolides]

But then donors would have a harder time then regular people

That doesn't make much sense.

Count how many donors actually play in a game also so when some tribute that is in 19 is safe and if anymore donors wanna come In they can kick

 

[mmagent27]

I want to see a clan tournament. You chose two of your best people from your clan and you compete. I would also like to have the old voting system back

 

[Zeno]

I want to see a clan tournament. You chose two of your best people from your clan and you compete.

Only two D:?

 

[soggypickle]

I'm seeing the ideas of the regular players not necessarily being in favor of donors. A weird idea that could work would perhaps be the person who is kicked to make room for a donor is completely random.

One other suggestion: please make it so servers don't restart. I have some non donor friends with slow computers that have trouble getting in servers as they fill. Although I recall this fixes "ghosting", I recall using an automatic /reload fixes ghosting too.

 

[due62]

One thing that i would like to see implemented is logout cooldowns.
by this i mean when you log out you don't get immediately eliminated from the games, but you have 30 seconds to log back in. This would be helpful because sometimes people's minecraft crashes when their in the middle of a game and they were having a "good" game. This feature would allow for people to not be kicked from the games if they crash.

Now I know people are going to say this:
"what about combat logging?"

My solution for that would be that if a player left the game and they had been hit in the last one minute then they would immediately loose.

 

[mmagent27]

Only two D:?

Only two D:?

Idk just a thought. Because there is a lot of clans you know