I know the post wasn't directed at me, but I'd like to answer the question, since I voted for Kharmunrah and Terewan. First of all, there's no error on your map. It's perfect for those whose MCSG styles are more geared towards fighting. It IS a small map, after all. There's not a lot of surviving and preparing to do. I prefer bigger maps like Terewan or Kharmunrah (or SG2) because my MCSG style is more based on survival. I PVP when necessary, but my goal is not to kill everyone whenever possible. I try to gather supplies from chests to prepare myself for the deathmatch if I survive that long. Your map (along with Breeze Island) would be perfect on a 12 player server if they existed. But I prefer playing larger maps on 24 or 48 player servers.
By the way, which servers are the new maps on? I can't find them.