Lets talk about SG2...

[Porkstorm]

Impressive aesthetically, however the gameplay lacks. Same goes for SG 2, 3 and 5.

SG1 is plain horrible.

Thought I was the only one who hated sg1 :3
Anyway sg2 is awesome but very rarely played.

 

[crazyzealots]

SG2 is severely underrated, The gameplay on the map is absolutely wonderful as well as the architecture.
I've never understood why it's outvoted by other maps because it is most definitely one of the best if not the best map in MCSG.

 

[flyon21]

Go play your Breeze Island.

^ Now THATS not a good map.

No, did I say I like Breeze? I'm just one of those guys that don't like maps most people like

 

[Kezzer]

SG2 is a good map however the issues with it are fairly well known. Due to the sheer size of it camping becomes a tactic that noobs use to survive and say "oh I came so close to winning as I made it to DM with a stick" It's a nice map but only works if more experienced players are in the game.

 

[teovald]

That moment sg2 is popular again mcsg will live again.

 

[Ceroria]

SG2 is a good map however the issues with it are fairly well known. Due to the sheer size of it camping becomes a tactic that noobs use to survive and say "oh I came so close to winning as I made it to DM with a stick" It's a nice map but only works if more experienced players are in the game.

People making it to DM with a stick give me free wins. I like SG2 for that very reason. And a lot of other underplayed, old maps. I get full iron, and kill all the peoples, take their sticks, and craft a lot of swords

 

[Henry]

Sg2 > All

Seriously though. Sg2 is awesome C:

 

[ToeKnee]

Ok I AB-SOUL-LOOT-LEE HATE SG2!!!!!

• The Gameplay is not "Great". It has some of the worst gameplay on the servers!
• Its extremely laggy for people who don't have godly computers.
• Yes the buildings are great, but the corn is awful, theres only like 4 OP chest routes. If you don't get one you're done.
• Nostalgia doesn't make a good map.

I don't get why people like SG2, its so awful!

Ew

 

[Nitro]

SG2 is my all time favourite map, so I completely agree with this thread.

 

[DreamNoodle]

I think the architecture in the map is fantastic, but I feel like there aren't enough chests around the map for it to be "perfect". At least with most new maps you can find some chests without having a set route and still potentially be okay. With this map I feel that if you don't have a route or a plan, you're done. Not necessarily a bad thing, but I feel like it could benefit from having more chests.

 

[Extramile]

I played on the first time it came out. Literally, the server restarted and the random selection put us on SG2..but I guess the games lasted for an hour and mobs scared the crap out of you in the buildings..fun

 

[Nitro]

I think the architecture in the map is fantastic, but I feel like there aren't enough chests around the map for it to be "perfect". At least with most new maps you can find some chests without having a set route and still potentially be okay. With this map I feel that if you don't have a route or a plan, you're done. Not necessarily a bad thing, but I feel like it could benefit from having more chests.

I think it's a good thing that there are few good routes, because it makes it more of a challenge to get stuff; you'll always have people following you.