If you had to judge SG1 like you judge new submissions...

[The Arena Master]

I'd probably still like it, but it's hard to say. I really love it because it mimics a hunger games feel for me. Always has, always will.

 

[Captain Dak]

Pretty darn good for PVP, actually. And I prefer a natural look for a map rather than gigantic, ridiculously over-the top-buildings everywhere. I guess I'm not much of a city person either in Minecraft or in real life, though those can be good for PVP as well.

 

[FuSioN]

*whispers
It was vanilla generated...

No it wasn't...

 

[RC_4777]

No it wasn't...

He's partly right. The world was generated by a special generator. So it was generated, but not vanilla.

 

[Hawk62]

Here's my honest map review.

Well, the terraforming is really good. It almost looks vanilla generated. Almost. The sheer amount of trees is astonishing, and not in a good way. The builds, the few there are, are decent. There is too much water. Add more landmass around the edge of the map. Also, add a ton of more builds. This entire map is trees. When I test played this map with a few friends, we had trouble finding any significant landmarks. The corn is really boring too. The large amount of one block wide lava traps really hurts this map. The large amount of the time they're hidden by grass, by the leaves of a tree, or just other things. All in all, I see potential. You need to add more builds to get my vote.

In reality, I love SG1 for what it is. It is the original. It's what sparked one of the biggest and most popular gamemode in Minecraft.

To be fair about the corn people said on a recent thread that they loved TSG 2's corn and it seemed to be the overall favorite for it simplicity. I feel like asking "why do people not like sg1's corn then?"

 

[Lively]

To be fair about the corn people said on a recent thread that they loved TSG 2's corn and it seemed to be the overall favorite for it simplicity. I feel like asking "why do people not like sg1's corn then?"

It just looks funky and seems out of place.

 

[ulthar]

Vareide had inspiration for Sg1 as soon as the movie came out. A foresty land scape with a couple structures and a modified plugin put together to make MCSG. As maps have progressed, they've gone farther away from maps that would've actually been featured in the legit hunger games. But we've modified it to make it playable, entertaining, enjoyable, and fun that has been played by over a million people in the past year and a half almost keep it going ChadTheDJ

 

[BritishShoop]

Idc it´s the first SG map ever, it sucks and I wouldn´t mind if they got rid of it.

Leave. Now.

 

[BlazeMaster]

This is a very serious question.

HOW THE HELL AM I NOT THE #1 MOST HATED IN MCSG FOR MAKING THAT MAP?!?!?!?!?!?!?

Jeez, I know people don't like it, cut me some slack ;_____;

Lets just revamp it to a sexy version.
Also SG1 wouldn't have much chance of being accepted but it was the first "good" survival games map ever made and it was the first on theses servers, it's a classic and I love it.