Those screenshots are in your favour as it says: 1) he was afk and didnt get back until later on 2)you said no Specs so he left and 3) when he left you didnt complain to us about it oyu just carried on lost and said you won. Leave my thread I dont want flame here and if you dont I shall get a mod. and dont even reply to this.
If you do want to argue about this somewhere else, please add me on skype, you haven't done that so this is the only way that i could communicate with you. Even though he was afk for a while, you still had to tell him when he got back which you did not. That's why I told him but he had already been spectating for a long time. I am not flaming on your thread, I'm simply trying to figure out how you couldn't see the rules as broken when the evidence is
very clear. If he was afk you should've though of it earlier when he was there (like when he did /kill in live game) so he did not spectate. As I've said several times, it's not our fault if your clan doesn't have a good communication in clan wars, but if that problem makes you break the rules, that is not ok.