You want to remove the low-quality maps?

[Honeypoo10]

You call this low-quality? That's sexy.

Shaders.....

 

[FuSioN]

Shaders.....

It looks sexy, even without shaders...

 

[ejegun]

Breeze isn't that bad quality

Yes it is. You don't know what quality means if you think it isn't that bad quality.

 

[yankees19971]

Remove Freeze island not demons, Freeze is so bad worst then the orginal, i would rather have water

 

[KaktusDE]

My personally...
Unlike Maps:
-Moonlight Lake
-Freeze Island (Nocheat+ on Ice, ruined my life) xD
-MoonBase9
-The new solar frost :/
-Wyverns Wake
Nice Maps:
-Rugged Lands
-TSG2
-Sg4
-Valleyside
-Holiday Resort

#AddBackLostMine2013!!!

 

[TheRandomMan1000]

The issue with this argument is, and the reason it's really very pointless: People have a different idea of what they consider a quality of a map, and where to draw the line from average to high quality. Seeing as the barriers do exist, it will be really impossible for everyone to agree on what maps are all around disliked, and what maps are good.
To do so we all need to define something:
What do you consider to be a quality adding feature to a map, and where do you draw the line between good and bad.
You all need to take that into account when you're angrily bashing each others opinions. Realize we all have different standards, and those of us that want to continue this debate, be sure to answer the bolded question above.

 

[Carz]

I'm still not seeing how Breeze is a low-quality map. I would be happy to see Moonlight Lake go, because it really is a HORRIBLE map. But some of the maps on MCSG really should be removed. And I think that everyone will know which maps I mean. (not Wyvern's Wake, that map is one of my favourites)

 

[Darby100]

You're missing my point.

A map that looks amazing, best builds, amazing terraforming etc. But say, is on an island like Breeze, wouldnt be added due to horrible gameplay.

My point was that, basically every map you find on the forums has good gameplay, the kind of maps that doesnt, are skylands, or ocean ones.

I don't understand. You just said maps should be added for looks not gameplay, now you are saying that maps shoulder be added for gameplay. Make
up your mind

 

[Darby100]

Yes it is. You don't know what quality means if you think it isn't that bad quality.

Breeze is a good quality map. Shown by the fact that it gets loads of votes, and is still around after so long.

Edit: Sorry for double post, didn't realize.

 

[ejegun]

Breeze is a good quality map. Shown by the fact that it gets loads of votes, and is still around after so long.

Edit: Sorry for double post, didn't realize.

You know that 95% of the people who vote for breeze only vote for it because they dont know what real quality is. And it has only been around for so long because all the noobs vote for it.

 

[Torchy // aezlurr]

So I'm that guy in the corner who actually ENJOYS Breeze Island.. xP.


Here's my opinion

BAD MAPS

-Destinys Shiver (I've played on it enough to judge it..bleh)
-Moonlight Lake
-Freeze Island (EW)
-Survival Kingdom (Once they remove God Apples I will enjoy this map.
- Survival Games 1

GOOD MAPS

-SG4/Breeze (I know they're overplayed, but they have good and enjoyable gameplay
-Holiday Resort
-Fortress Pyke
-Avaricia
-Solar Frost
-Demons Breeze
-Rugged Lands

 

[FuSioN]

You know that 95% of the people who vote for breeze only vote for it because they dont know what real quality is. And it has only been around for so long because all the noobs vote for it.

First off, your definition of quality may be different from others. IMO, and a lot of other people's opinion, Breeze is a great map. Obviously in yours it isn't. Secondly, making the generalization that only noobs vote Breeze Island is false. I vote for Breeze Island, and I'm not a noob.