The Walking Dead - Season 3 Finale

[TheRandomMan1000]

For all who saw it.... OPINIONS!

 

[Ikanacanyon7]

For all who saw it.... OPINIONS!

It got me really pissed off that they got Andrea out -_- REALLY... Her character was amazing to me....

 

[TheRandomMan1000]

It got me really pissed off that they got Andrea out -_- REALLY... Her character was amazing to me....

At least she got to take herself out, it would have been a shame if they walked in to Milton eating her corpse. Which brings me to another point, I really liked Milton too Sad he died, but at least he attempted to kill Phillip. Stupid jerk that Phillip is.

 

[Ikanacanyon7]

At least she got to take herself out, it would have been a shame if they walked in to Milton eating her corpse. Which brings me to another point, I really liked Milton too Sad he died, but at least he attempted to kill Phillip. Stupid jerk that Phillip is.

Yeah they really did that scene very well... though I feel that making Andrea die made Miltons death (and the subsecuent scenes after that) pointless since she died anyways I have already accpeted that shes dead but I still think there was a lot more to her character than making her die there.. I mean... In the comic book she is still alive! (I havent read them but thats one of the few things I know)
The other two things I didnt like is that I felt they made the attack to the prison far too short, even if they made very good scenes out of that part; and the other thing that bothered me was that they let The Governor (Phillip) live through this season... I hardly beleive that wasnt a good desition... it makes the show get frozen at a problem wich was given too much time on air already... I think they should have ended it there already so they could move on to something else....

Appart from that this season finale was very good and Im glad they finally didnt leave us with a cliffhanger and istead with a little bit of peace.

 

[TheRandomMan1000]

Yeah they really did that scene very well... though I feel that making Andrea die made Miltons death (and the subsecuent scenes after that) pointless since she died anyways I have already accpeted that shes dead but I still think there was a lot more to her character than making her die there.. I mean... In the comic book she is still alive! (I havent read them but thats one of the few things I know)
The other two things I didnt like is that I felt they made the attack to the prison far too short, even if they made very good scenes out of that part; and the other thing that bothered me was that they let The Governor (Phillip) live through this season... I hardly beleive that wasnt a good desition... it makes the show get frozen at a problem wich was given too much time on air already... I think they should have ended it there already so they could move on to something else....

Appart from that this season finale was very good and Im glad they finally didnt leave us with a cliffhanger and istead with a little bit of peace.

Agreed. What about the guy Carl shot in the face? Idk what I think about it, but what do you think?

 

[Ikanacanyon7]

Agreed. What about the guy Carl shot in the face? Idk what I think about it, but what do you think?

Well... From my perspective... It was completely unnecessary... but his reasons to do it where justified at the point of view of a 13 year old kid who is starting to grow up in such a world.
I think it was amazingly clever to give us a reminder of the character who died all the way on season 2 right after Rick said Carl is a kid and he forgets easily... what Carl said prooved him wrong.
He didnt kill that walker at the swamp, Dale got killed by it. Rick didnt kill Andrew (the last remaining bad prisoner) and it costed Lori's and T-Dog's life. He didnt kill the Governor when he met him, it made all of this problem go on and it costed Merle's life and also Miltons and Andrea's life (even if Carl didnt knew that at that time)

 

[TheRandomMan1000]

Well... From my perspective... It was completely unnecessary... but his reasons to do it where justified at the point of view of a 13 year old kid who is starting to grow up in such a world.
I think it was amazingly clever to give us a reminder of the character who died all the way on season 2 right after Rick said Carl is a kid and he forgets easily... what Carl said prooved him wrong.
He didnt kill that walker at the swamp, Dale got killed by it. Rick didnt kill Andrew (the last remaining bad prisoner) and it costed Lori's and T-Dog's life. He didnt kill the Governor when he met him, it made all of this problem go on and it costed Merle's life and also Miltons and Andrea's life (even if Carl didnt knew that at that time)

Yep, while I think it wasn't justified to kill that particular guy, his reasons were in order. If you go back to mid season 2 you even get another taste of what happens. Rick didn't kill hostage-guy and that lead to the farm being vulnerable. Carl is following the governors idea of you kill you live you die you kill.

 

[Ikanacanyon7]

Yep, while I think it wasn't justified to kill that particular guy, his reasons were in order. If you go back to mid season 2 you even get another taste of what happens. Rick didn't kill hostage-guy and that lead to the farm being vulnerable. Carl is following the governors idea of you kill you live you die you kill.

Yeah pretty much... but still... Carl MAY have had his reasons in order there but I still dont think that was the way to execute them... there should be a balance between that Ideal and the one of trusting new people.
If rick would have been more acceptive of new people and would have trusted more... there would have been WAY less trouble... but yet... at the same time it would have been a HUGE risk (like with the prisoners for example).
God... this TV show brings so many dilemmas... I absolutely LOVE it for that

 

[RC_4777]

I will take up that stabbing offer now Random.

 

[VebbiHD]

I really liked it!
So...what's it about?

 

[TheRandomMan1000]

"... You will find something sharp and stab me in the head, that is what you will do."

 

[iMightTroll]

Did all the zombies die?