• Our Minecraft servers are offline but we will keep this forum online for any community communication. Site permissions for posting could change at a later date but will remain online.

How Far is Too Far? (#1): Genetics.

What is your opinion on genectically modifying things?

  • EW

  • Sure I guess…

  • Meh.


Results are only viewable after voting.

SnoopSean

Career
Joined
Aug 5, 2014
Messages
820
Reaction score
646
7th Grade BIO LEZ GO.
So today I was watching some video on genetic engineering/selection stuff and it talked about how it's a controversial thing that "Should this be used or not?"
Today I will focus on the changing of the code of life for our 'benefits'. But are they truly beneficial?
Let's start at food, GMO foods are foods that's DNA has been changed to be more e.g. resistant to the cold (tomatoes with an arctic anti-freeze gene), much larger, and less diverse. The manipulation of this is what is causing all the buzz, and the fact that we don't even label these things is another point to the argument of GMO foods.
While yes, you can grow more things and have enough food, we already have enough. 1.5 times more that enough. And while it prevents famine, the money going to GMO foods could be going to those "3rd world" countries. People also think that this GMO stuff could harm us, even though that plenty of scientists have proven that it's fine. Still, many people think it's, inhuman.
Now comes the medicine. Insulin, stuff that helps your liver store sugar so you don't go into a sugar colma (it's diabetic colma BTW your brain shuts down) can be made. It's made from splicing DNA and inserting it back with the use of bacteria. Again, here's where the protests come, saying that it could have some consequences and stuff like that. But again, here, people say it's inhuman.
And here's where stuff gets iffy. And where scientists take off their glasses and say, well then. Choosing your DNA. Not yours necessarily, but choosing your kids DNA. Making a "perfect child" seems desirable, right? Perhaps not…
Scientists believe it's too hard to just switch everything out, and because our genome is so complex, it will have mistakes, mistakes that are unavoidable.
But it's not just that. In the book The Giver there is a prominence of a utopian society. One that, and even mentioned in the book, has geneticists hard at work, eliminating things like choice, (color stuff), emotions, stuff that seems crazy and outlandish. But how outlandish is this? How close are we to this type of society, and will we go in mindlessly, or will we stop and think.
Have we gone too far?
 

Mamiamato24

Diamond
Joined
Apr 20, 2012
Messages
7,395
Reaction score
19,215
Well GMOs have their advantages and their disadvantages, most of which are risks that genetic diversity will be lacking. However, this is only really pertinent to plants. Genetics and transgenesis hasn't exactly been tested very much on humans, like cloning and changing one's genome. I think it'll be a relatively long while before these things actually get out of hand and we end up in a situation like The Giver. People will primarily have to get over it being "inhumane" and embracing it's advantages. As I said, the progress on humans in the field is quite sluggish. Scientists have cloned multiple animal species, inserted or retrieved segments of DNA, etc, but it will take a while before experimentation on humans could take place.
 

Rhino1928

Peacekeeper
Joined
Aug 22, 2012
Messages
1,869
Reaction score
1,750
I really don't have a problem with GMO's, they are safe.

But I will correct you on what you said about ''Insulin". Having lived with Type 1 Diabetes for 10+ years, I happen to know a thing or two. Insulin that is made for people suffering from Type 1 Diabetes is identical to the kind produced by the body, due to modern science. Now about this whole "Sugar Coma" thing, probably the most common rumor about Diabetes is this whole "Do you have to watch what you eat?" "Can you not have sugar?!?!?" "Do you have to only have sugar-free items?". The answer is no, people with Type 1 Diabetes can eat whatever they want, when they want as long as they give insulin for the amount of carbohydrates eaten. If a Diabetic though does not treat for the amount of insulin, or comes down with the flu. He/She can fall into what is known as "DKA" or Diabetic Keto-Acidosis, and your Kidneys, Bladder begin to shutdown, along with this comes the dehydration which in turn has your body pump all of its fluids to the brain causing your brain to swell and fail due to pressure. Lastly, your liver does not need sugar to stay alive if you have Diabetes.

Pretty much the end of my rant. Have a nice day.
 

Members online

No members online now.

Forum statistics

Threads
242,192
Messages
2,449,550
Members
523,970
Latest member
Atasci