1. MaxhiXBL - not overrated, OP fishing rod
2. Gravey4rd - not overrated, very good at the game.
3. Joethepro15 - beats me a lot more than I beat him I hate him so much nub, jk<3
4. Araxed - Great overall player.
5. Ryska_Ryssen - Not played much with you to be fair but have some decent fights with you.
6. Salared - I think this guy is kinda underrated imo, I love the aggressive tactic as most top players play very defensive.
7. Nickvdpas073 - This guy is one of my favourite players, very good and underrated imo.
8. mice9cunt
- Good overall player
9. DW1998 - We don't exactly get on but still worthy of being a top PvPer although I feel he uses fns alot too like Reven86 & CHRISGUNNING but is capable of using other tactics other than fns.
10. Zethiz/emilpiva - Talented player also underrated.
I haven't played/don't remember playing:
Elgodo, xExtract, Teku30, Chuckboy, Deadkillz, CharlesYummyEgg, DahMike, Ziiinc, Easy_Soup, ExKing, Guy_Chaos, Kallbergz all I've heard are good.
People I'd say are great PvPers and deserve a mention atleast:
brynemannen8, Cizzle1, Randy_Nub, Austin_HG, TF1xHD, NoahSailer, jdgoederen, arontjuuh, jaaayx, ZeLiiiKaHD, I_Am_Mr_Slash3r, Sayfisac, Master_Kezo, SenchSlash, Glasgowdude, Sylaana, Tobschiller, AW1996, Deggerbug. I'd like to say Geocraftable and WeRCreeper even though I highly dislike how these two people act, seriously if you lose to these then you'll hear it forever they're big headed like that.
People saying overrated players:
They're not overrated at all, they're just great pvpers who people obviously talk about therefore you get the image they're overrated.
"I beat some of the people before" - not everyone is always top of their game, I know myself I am a very inconsistent player and have been beat by probably everyone on MCSG and I've beat others who are great PvPers does not mean I'm the better player at all.
Said I wasn't going to do one of these but well some of these seem very biased towards their friends or people they know well. Mine only includes people I've played and is all my opinion.