Top 5 (Multiple categories)

[Nebulousity]

Fishing rod: SteelFlexer, LinkDude, Soul and SwagGiraffe
Flint and Steel: Crafty and Huahwi.. (Idk many other good F&S'rs)
Bow: killerkons, Love and Bom
Sword: Bom, LinkDude, egrodo..

 

[inconceivable81]

Fishing rod:
darkrai202 - Fishing rod vs. stone sword? Easy for him!
xExtract - The one thing I don't get is how he manages to get hits at the same time as using the rod...
CraftyKratonite - His kill montage shows his abusing the rod again and again...
Henkcraft - I once saw him die! (Off spawn)
DeadStrikers10 - Watching him taking out a 2-team of hackers was... Fun...

Flint and Steel:
(Note: Macros are nooby and obvious)
I just don't find it challenging to dodge any flint and steels, and I don't consider macros to be skill in the slightest, so I will leave this blank.

Bow:
inconceivable81 - I am like Darkrai202, if I deserve to be here, I will put myself here
brynemannen8 - Used to consider him the best... Now I've improved a lot and he hasn't much. Now I just consider him good...
EdtheG - Don't really know how he is now, but when we used to team (ages ago), I had to do extremely well to beat him in a 1v1 because of his bow.
ILoveNash - I know he's banned, but he is the other person that I could never beat with my eyes closed...
Elgoldo - Well, I suppose his tactic works for bow spam...

Sword:
VitalReaper (no forum) - Just because his stats and other tactics aren't great, doesn't make his sword skills not count!
Haven't seen anyone else that I can't beat in a sword 1v1

 

[darkai202]

Fishing rod:
darkrai202 - Fishing rod vs. stone sword? Easy for him!

HAHAH I REMEMBER THAT :')

 

[leMaCderp]

oh wait this is mcsg
probably most of the old Phoenix members are the top (AU)
if you mean global, i'd say Cayden, HattoWolf, MrM00se, JohnFairfax and Liftie. these guys are IMO the best pvpers I've ever seen (PotPvP in general)
in terms of bow, I'd say MK325, Matsuzen, BillabongBoy98, Kytria, and DragonTixan? idkkk

 

[Weary]

NO ORDER

Fishing rod: croe97 , stigjam89, notverified, blakew447, DinoDan
Flint and Steel: notverified, csimp8444, maljack007, jayalibrodie01, N1NJAMANPRO
Bow: flok, shinyigglybuff, thedorkyd1, Billa, Kytria
Sword: Billa, Da_Goose22, Lreeves, mustyleaf4, kooksey99

 

[le quack]

Here are mine
(Note: AS Player)
(Note2: I will be including myself is necessary, if you disagree feel free to comment )

Fishing rod:
Myself - In near-death situations when I have a fishing rod I tend to win the fights
PvP_Baby - Rod spams alot keeping his opponents away to harm him.
Flint and Steel:
MVPThomas - This guy knows where to place the FnS making it hard to dodge most of the times.
T0PlaysMC - His FnS is extremely quick making it hard to avoid
Bow:
Legit_Proph3t - Doesn't miss a shot...... Like seriously..... Just miss once please
MighyJack - Lands most shots but has gotten a bit worse.
Sword:
Vareidy - Sword fight with him your dead, Very good at following the player
DoodleeldooD - Can still sword PvP really well even without secondary's

 

[dq]

Fishing rod: BomBashious , Apzy , JustlThelWorst , G33ke , FuzzyPB
Flint and Steel: TOXICWASTEII , gcb99 ,CraftyKratonite
Bow: iancool , Linkdude1997 , Branbob83
Sword: Lovelights , ManOfTheBread , Billa , Cscoop , Huahwi

Cant think of anymore atm.

 

[YoungWolfyy_]

Here are mine
(Note: AS Player)
(Note2: I will be including myself is necessary, if you disagree feel free to comment )

Fishing rod:
Myself - In near-death situations when I have a fishing rod I tend to win the fights
PvP_Baby - Rod spams alot keeping his opponents away to harm him.
Flint and Steel:
MVPThomas - This guy knows where to place the FnS making it hard to dodge most of the times.
T0PlaysMC - His FnS is extremely quick making it hard to avoid
Bow:
Legit_Proph3t - Doesn't miss a shot...... Like seriously..... Just miss once please
MighyJack - Lands most shots but has gotten a bit worse.
Sword:
Vareidy - Sword fight with him your dead, Very good at following the player
DoodleeldooD - Can still sword PvP really well even without secondary's

i cri, but I understand. I'm too bad for you..

 

[Tironas11]

Fishing Rod: xSwagGiraffe BomBashious
Flint and Steel: JustlThelWorst Soulv2 CraftyKratonite Huahwi
Bow: xExtract BomBashious (remember our old fights on swish where we'd get eachother down to like 2 hearts and charge at eachother ) Rexxy, JustlThelWorst and trying not to be cocky but I'd put myself on this list. I'm decent at regular shots but with 180 bow shots I'm very deadly.
Sword: xSwagGiraffe Huahwi

 

[xSwagGiraffe]

Ye that's right I am the best

 

[le quack]

i cri, but I understand. I'm too bad for you..

I wanted to but 2 each you are all rounder not really good at a specific one

 

[inconceivable81]

I love how I am the only one that put someone with bad stats on my list...